Party Games
40 Music Would You Rather Questions for Your Next Party
Forty original music would you rather questions in five themes, with a short guide to why they work and how to run them with a group.
By The Editors ยท
"Would you rather" is one of the easiest party games to start. You need no board, no cards and no music knowledge. You ask a question with two options, everyone picks one, and then people explain themselves. Music makes it better, because almost everybody has strong feelings about it.
Why music would you rather questions work
- There is no right answer. Nobody can be wrong, so nobody feels tested. Quiet players join in.
- Both options pull at you. A good question is a real dilemma. If the whole room picks the same side in a second, the question is too easy.
- They start stories. The pick is only the beginning. The best part is hearing why.
- They need no expertise. These questions are about taste and habits, not facts.
How to use this list
- Read a question aloud, count to three and have everyone answer at once.
- Ask one person from each side to defend their pick in a sentence.
- Do not allow "both" or "neither". Choosing is the game.
- Jump between themes to keep the room guessing.
Every question below starts with the same four words: would you rather...
Listening habits
- ...hear every new song a week before anyone else, or rediscover one forgotten favourite every week?
- ...listen through one earbud for a year, or only through your phone speaker?
- ...never be able to skip a song again, or never be able to replay one?
- ...lose every playlist you have made, or never be able to make a new one?
- ...only hear songs shorter than three minutes, or only songs longer than six?
- ...show everyone you know your full listening history, or never see your own yearly stats again?
- ...play one song on repeat for a whole day, or a thousand songs for ten seconds each?
- ...get a perfect playlist handed to you every morning, or build every playlist yourself?
Concerts and live music
- ...stand at the barrier for a four-hour show, or sit in comfort at the very back?
- ...watch a great band play to an empty room, or an average band play to a wild crowd?
- ...hear your favourite song first, or wait all night for it as the encore?
- ...go to every concert alone, or always go with someone who talks through the songs?
- ...camp in the mud for a perfect festival line-up, or sleep in a hotel for a weak one?
- ...be handed the microphone for one chorus, or catch a drumstick at the end?
- ...stand behind someone filming the whole show, or beside someone singing every word off-key?
- ...see a show where phones are banned, or own a perfect recording of a show you missed?
Making music
- ...write a song that makes people cry, or one that makes people dance?
- ...be a brilliant drummer nobody notices, or an average singer everybody watches?
- ...finish one decent song every day, or one perfect song every year?
- ...have your first song be your biggest, or your last?
- ...play every instrument a little, or one instrument better than anyone you know?
- ...write the tune and let someone else write the words, or write the words and hand over the tune?
- ...record in a famous studio against the clock, or in your bedroom with all the time in the world?
- ...hear your song in an advert you dislike, or never have it heard at all?
Eras and time travel
- ...live before recorded music, when every song was played in person, or a hundred years from now?
- ...keep the music of your teenage years forever, or always love whatever is new?
- ...own one record a month and know it by heart, or have everything and know none of it well?
- ...bring back handwritten track lists, or bring back phoning a radio station to request a song?
- ...play your favourite song to your grandparents, or hear the song they loved most at your age?
- ...bring back your favourite decade's music along with its haircuts, or leave both in the past?
- ...know today which current songs will still be loved in fifty years, or be surprised?
- ...hear today's hits played by an old-time dance band, or old standards remade with modern production?
Parties, road trips and everyday life
- ...run the playlist at every party and take the blame, or never touch it and never complain?
- ...drive ten hours with a single album, or with a radio that changes station after every song?
- ...wake up to a new song picked by a stranger each day, or to the same song forever?
- ...sing karaoke in front of your colleagues, or dance alone at a wedding for one whole song?
- ...have your shower singing played to the whole street, or your car singing played to the car behind?
- ...only exercise to slow ballads, or only fall asleep to fast dance music?
- ...let your best friend choose your first-dance song, or let your parents choose your party playlist?
- ...have a sad song play whenever you tell a fib, or a love song play whenever your crush walks in?
Write your own
Once the list runs out, the room can make more. A few rules help.
- Balance the options. Both should be tempting, or both should be awful.
- Keep it short. If a question needs explaining, it is too long.
- Be specific. "Ten hours with a single album" is easier to picture than "a long time with limited music".
- Keep it kind. Aim the question at habits and taste, not at a person in the room.
Play it online
If you would like the questions dealt for you, try music would you rather on this site. Play solo to see how other players voted, or open a private room, where nobody sees the split until everyone has picked a side. When the room is warmed up, move on to an aux battle and let people back their opinions with a song.